Francophobia or Ignorance?

by Lyne des Roberts alias La Dame dragon

While surfing the net, the other day, looking for some newspapers’ articles relevant to training among Canadian civil servants; I accidently came across a website that gave me the creeps…

I will not give the link because I do not want to publicize thoughts and opinions that are expressed on that site. The few lines I read made me feel as if I had landed in some neo-nazi or KKK territory. Of course, everything is under the cover of anonymity… all I know is that it is run by a group of Canadian civil servants (apparently based in the NCR) who describe themselves as oppressed! I doubt they really know what being oppressed means!

At first glance, it looks like these people only want to fight language policies and regulations in the Public Service of Canada which they consider as disenfranchising unilingual civil servants. On their home page, they posted numerous newspapers’ articles regarding training and testing. On one of them, referring to the fact that 97% of the training was in French vs 3% in English, they candidly suggest that the Governement should “educate” that 3% and leave the remaining 97% alone. What they probably do not know is that, between October 1, 2007 and January 16, 2008, 3,687 candidates were tested in French vs 4,320 in English… Bilinguism (when it does apply to certain job positions within the Government) is required from all civil servants (Anglophones, Francophones and Allophones) and English-speaking people are not treated differently… if there is less training in English, it only indicates that Francophones and Allophones are already fluent in English.

I can understand that some frustrated and jaded civil servants would like to see bilingual positions return to unilingual, unfortunately that will not happen! Therefore, I was wondering about the purpose of such a website… it is when I clicked on different links that I realized it has nothing to do with training and testing. If so, there would not be a list of inequities between Québec and the rest of Canada!

Also, they state that Québec is unilingual French (I am originally from Montréal and it is a plurilingual city!) and only 4% of the population outside this province speak French (of course, the source of this information is not mentioned anywhere). According to Statistics Canada, in 2001, Canadians’ mother tongues were 58.55% English, 22.62% French and 18.83% others… for a total of 41.45% of the population speaking another language than English. And, between 2001 and 2006, the immigration rate grew by 13.6% (adding to the percentage of people whose mother tongue is not English). And, something very interesting here: in 2006, only 27.1% of Toronto, Montréal and Vancouver population were Canadian Born… Many immigrants are trilingual (especially in Québec)… With such a large number of people born outside the country, it is only fair to have two official languages in Canada (depending on where they settle down, they might choose to speak either English or French: we live in a free country, don’t we?). Therefore, let’s not speak any longer about the vast majority of native unilingual English Canadians… this majority is drastically on the decline!

My fear is that discouraged civil servants, after having gone through months of FSL training and keeping failing the tests, might rally such a group. The mere idea that I can be surrounded by some of those Francophobics when I go from one Department to another makes me sick! But, since I am an optimistic individual, I like to believe that this group is not as large as they pretend to be: when I look at how popular French Immersion schools are in Ottawa (kids attending those schools obviously have open-minded parents), it tells me I do not live in a town infested with Francophobics after all

Already one Federal Department has censored this site and the “oppressed” ask people to re-register using their personal email address, accusing the Department of denying them freedom of speech. Freedom of speech? This site is about propaganda… not about opinions. And why would they ask for donations if it were only a platform for venting and whining?

I am 100% in favor of bilinguism… and civil servants are very lucky to be able to learn a second language on the job with their full salary and training entirely paid by their employer. And I do firmly believe that the majority of them are in favor of learning French… being bilingual is an asset for life, not just a position’s requirement.

Yes! Things could be improved… training could be enjoyable and testing could be less dreadful… right now it is not! Because people are taught to the tests from day one until the very end : something that may last more than a year… Then they must pass tests that do not reflect reality, often more than three times… Consequently they end up feeling stupid and totally disgusted with French.

I do train civil servants and I teach them the way I know as being the best: I teach them French for any life situations… I give them exposure to French-Canadian culture… I bank on their life experience and creativity to make their learning experience relevant and interesting… and I never talk about the tests! When they are scheduled for evaluation, then I submit them to an excruciating drill… except that it does not last more than a couple of weeks. When they are tested, they DO get their levels… if not the first time, the second time. And they all have good memories of their training…

All we need is a better system… it is feasible if the right issues are raised and the questionable testing tools are seriously re-examined… A website such as the one I found is definitely not the solution!

This blog move here, if you ever are interested in reading more on those issues…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: